May 12, 2012

Between Shades of Gray

by Ruta Sepetys
ages: 13+
First sentence: "They took me in my nightgown."
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

It's 1941. Police come in the night, taking a family by force, without explanation. They are taken to a train station, shoved into cattle cars with hundreds of other people, and taken -- beaten, abused, shot, starved -- to a camp where they are forced to work.

If you didn't see the year, you would probably think this was a Holocaust book. It is, but not Hitler and Jews. It's Stalin and the Lithuanians.

Our narrator is 15-year-old Lina, the oldest child of a university professor, an artist. She and her family are taken, separated -- her mother bribes the NKVD (the precursor to the KGB) to keep her and her two children, Lina and Jonas together -- and sent to work in the camps. They are branded traitors, criminals, prostitutes, anti-Soviet, and are sent to work initially at a beet farm. They are not treated well, to say the least, but there are moments -- like Christmas, or the way the Lithuanians help each other -- that are more humane. Then, inexplicably, Lina and her family are sent off to the Arctic Circle, to work in a camp there. In one of the more harrowing moments, an American ship ports and brings tons of supplies, all of which the NKVD officers get, and none of which go to the inmates (which the Americans don't even know are there). So many people freeze to death; so many people lose hope.

It's a harrowing book, disturbing, and as Maggie Stiefvater said, completely wrecked me. I could only read it in short chunks, interspersing it with something lighter, because that's all I could handle. I couldn't tell you about the writing, or the characters, or whether or not I liked it, because (like many Holocaust books), I couldn't get past the fact that this was based on true events.

Which means, this now takes its place among those books that are Important and Should Be Read. If only so Lina's -- and Lithuania's -- story can be heard.


A Jane of All Reads said...

Fabulous review. I've heard that it was one of those books you were suppose to read, even if you didn't necessarily want to. It's difficult to go into a book that you already know is NOT going to be a good time.

Miss K said...

I agree with the capitalized Important and Should Be Read. I found the characters, especially the mother, to be wonderful.

Amanda said...

I want to read this book so badly. I got it from the library once, and tried to read it, and I got as far as the second chapter or so before I just couldn't handle it anymore. It was so intense, so good, and was already tearing me apart. I knew there was no way I could handle the rest, so I turned it back in so I could save it for a day when I was a bit stronger. I'm not sure that day will ever come. Still, one of these days, I WILL buckle down and read this, even if, like you, I have to break it into chunks just to survive the reading.

Kailana said...

I have had this book on my wish list for ages. One of these days I must read it!

Corinne said...

I've maybe read too many hard-core, adult Holocaust books, since this one didn't disturb me as much as it did other people. I really liked it a lot, and it made me think, but I didn't find it that hard to read. That's probably not a good thing :)

Melissa Mc (Gerbera Daisy Diaries) said...

I just finished this a few days was tough for me too. Not sure I "enjoyed" it...but certainly appreciated it, and thought the author did a wonderful job telling the story. The end was abrupt. But oh well.
Here is my review: